Lean Enterprise Institute Logo
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter Signup
  • Cart (0)
  • Account
  • Search
Lean Enterprise Institute Logo
  • Explore Lean
        • What is Lean?
        • The Lean Transformation Framework
        • A Brief History of Lean
        • Lexicon Terms
        • Topics to explore
          • Operations
          • Lean Product & Process Development
          • Administration & Support
          • Problem-Solving
          • Coaching
          • Executive Leadership
          • Line Management
  • The Lean Post
        • Subscribe to see exclusive content
          • Subscribe
        • Featured posts
          Leaper climbing to goal

          Understanding Lean Thinking and Practice Fundamentals

          Twi cards on a cork board

          Understanding the True Value of the TWI...

          • See all Posts
  • Events & Training
        • Leadership Coaching and Custom Training
        • What is a Co-Learning Partnership (CLP)?
        • Forms and Templates
        • Featured learning
          • Improvement Kata/Coaching Kata Remotely

            April 10, 2023 | Online Live Course

          • Developing Structured Problem-Solving and Leadership Skills using A3 Thinking: Managing to Learn Remotely

            April 17, 2023 | Online Live Course

          • Hoshin Kanri Remotely: Aligning and Executing on Your Organizational Objectives

            April 21, 2023 | Online Live Course

          • Designing the Future Remotely: A Lean Product Development Immersive Learning Experience

            April 24, 2023 | Online Live Course

          • See all Events
  • Store
        • Shopping Cart
        • Featured books
          Managing to Learn: Using the A3 management process

          Managing to Learn: Using the A3 management process

          Learning to See

          Learning to See

          • See all Books
  • About Us
        • Our people
          • Senior Advisors and Staff
          • Faculty
          • Board of Directors
        • Contact Us
        • Lean Global Network
        • Press Releases
        • In the News
        • Careers
        • About us

The Lean Post / Articles / Why should I manage as if I had no power when power is the most effective way of getting things done?

Article graphic image with repeating icons

Line Management

Why should I manage as if I had no power when power is the most effective way of getting things done?

By Michael Ballé

February 18, 2019

Dear Gemba Coach: I’m tired of hearing I should manage as if I had no power. Surely power is the most effective way of getting things done, isn’t it?

FacebookTweetLinkedInEmailPrintComment

Dear Gemba Coach,

I’m tired of hearing I should manage as if I had no power. Surely power is the most effective way of getting things done, isn’t it?

Good point. Yes, power is the best way of getting things done – but not getting them to stay done.

Command and control get things done, no debate. Tell people what to do, make sure they do it or else – truth or consequences. Things will get done. But haven’t you noticed how they backslide? How results evaporate and the same problems come back time and time again?

Look at all the examples we have around us of someone using their clout to get things their way. First, they’re praised as such a doer. Then people grumble and grumble. Middle-management starts to lie to protect the leader from the reality of the frontline. Then fires break out faster than you can put them down. Finally, the organization is in even worse shape than before and everyone vilifies the one-time great leader.

I can’t think of any more spectacular example that Jack Welch’s GE – getting things done indeed! Welch was nicknamed “Neutron Jack” for eliminating employees while leaving buildings intact.[19] In Jack: Straight From The Gut, he says that GE had 411,000 employees at the end of 1980, and 299,000 at the end of 1985. Of the 112,000 who left the payroll, 37,000 were in businesses that GE sold, and 81,000 were reduced in continuing businesses, basic research, and closed or sold-off businesses that were under-performing (What it says in Wikipedia, anyhow).

We now know what a scam it all was and that Welch’s GE was an even bigger scandal than Enron, but at the time it was very seductive. I know, I studied GE closely wondering what would be the better continuous improvement model to commit to: GE’s six sigma and “workouts” or Toyota’s TPS.

Management Shock and Awe

I was on the gemba yesterday visiting a plant where the manager changed about a year ago. The previous guy had set up the plant as a greenfield and grew it to a volume of, say, 1,000 a day. He left because he had been promised a second greenfield to build, but in fact, the CEO decided to lean the plant and increase output in the existing facility.

He was a great manager by power standards: getting things done, making his case forcefully, surrounded by a loyal cadre of officers. But there was always a new crisis. No supplies (had to fire a bad supplier), no staff  (no more operators in the region), wrong demand mix, etc. And of course, never time for kaizen.

With the new manager, the plant now hits 3,000 a day on a good day. There are no crises. The atmosphere is easy going and friendly, the kaizen proposals from employees are incredible.

It’s not that the previous manager didn’t do improvements – he did, plenty. When asked forcefully enough, he delivered. But it didn’t stick. With the new PM, everything is lower key, messier, not so controlled, but he works with his people every day and changes stick – so progress is continuous and cumulative. And the plant is transformed.

Western management theory is one of overwhelming force. Yes, it gets things done. When you have a strong advantage (say, bigger guns or proprietary technology) and an open field, don’t bother with lean – just get it done. The downside is that if never sticks. The deal forced out of people without equivalent progress in the relationship and education simply unravels later.

The U.S. won the Vietnam war militarily. It won the Afghan war militarily. It certainly won both Iraqi wars. We know how well all of that panned out.

The lean approach of managing as if you had no power is the key to making fixed problems stay fixed.Messy but Lasting

Lean management theory is one of adaptiveness. If you build strong relationships with allies through a common goal of bringing value faster to customers and society, and through working together on kaizen projects, you develop mutual respect and a shared understanding of the world. You don’t impose your sole will on the world. You respond to challenges with friends, and learn how to deal with obstacles, and make positive changes that stick.

The lean approach of managing as if you had no power is the key to making fixed problems stay fixed.

Sure, it takes longer. Sure it’s messier and dicier as people have different, muddled opinions about situations and their own ideas about where to start and how to go about it. Which is precisely what makes the lean strategy adaptive.

For instance, the moment you set a product introduction takt time, everything changes. The problems you immediately face are:

  • What do our customers like about our product (our heritage) and what should we change to be in the spirit of the times (where is our legacy)?
  • Who do I need to work with to deliver at takt?
  • What are the main technical obstacles we need to face before we start doing all the hard work?
  • Which resources do we need to prepare now because we’ll need them later?
  • What are the key innovations I really need to get to grips with?

These simple questions are adaptive – they will make you change your mind early on about the new product – and if they can’t all be resolved this time around, we’ll keep working at it for next time. The alternative is deciding the current product has exhausted its current marketing potential and deciding that “we need X and Y to survive so I want you to do A, B, and C.”  Then use all your power to sell it to customers, make your people deliver, and squeeze your suppliers – classic Porter strategy.

There are no absolutes. Yang turns into yin, yin turns into yang. Yes, there are situations, unique opportunities where one has to move fast and burn the boats and where, absolutely, the naked use of power and overwhelming force will get the job done. But will it get you what you want? It will if you can cash out.

Otherwise, you’re likely to have to deal with the consequences later on. In this case, an adaptive lean approach is messier and apparently longer to get started (in real life, it isn’t), but it will deliver lasting solutions to the problems you’re facing and improve your competitive position sustainably. As one of my sensei used to say, “It really depends on which problem you’re trying to solve.”

FacebookTweetLinkedInEmailPrintComment

Written by:

Michael Ballé

About Michael Ballé

Michael Ballé is co-author of The Gold Mine, a best-selling business novel of lean turnaround, and recently The Lean Manager, a novel of lean transformation, both published by the Lean Enterprise Institute. For the past 25 years, he has studied lean transformation and helped companies develop a lean culture. He is…

Read more about Michael Ballé

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related

Turner Case Study: Lean in Construction

Line Management

Respect for People: Making the Job Easier for Workers

Case Study by David Drickhamer

businessman at start line

Line Management

Managing the Work from Startup to Scaleup

Article by Michael Ballé and Nicolas Chartier

data center

Line Management

Improving the Value-Creating Work of Building Data Centers Around the World

Article by Lean Leaper

Related books

Toyota Way of Dantotsu Cover

The Toyota Way of Dantotsu Radical Quality Improvement (Paperback)

by Sadao Nomura

The Gold Mine Trilogy 4 Book Set

The Gold Mine Trilogy 4 Book Set

by Freddy Ballé and Michael Ballé

Related events

April 17, 2023 | Online Live Course

Developing Structured Problem-Solving and Leadership Skills using A3 Thinking: Managing to Learn Remotely

Learn more

April 21, 2023 | Online Live Course

Hoshin Kanri Remotely: Aligning and Executing on Your Organizational Objectives

Learn more

Explore topics

Line Management graphic icon Line Management

Subscribe to get the very best of lean thinking delivered right to your inbox

Subscribe
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

©Copyright 2000-2023 Lean Enterprise Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
Lean Enterprise Institute, the leaper image, and stick figure are registered trademarks of Lean Enterprise Institute, Inc.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Learn More. ACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT
Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!