Lean Enterprise Institute Logo
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter Signup
  • Cart (0)
  • Account
  • Search
Lean Enterprise Institute Logo
  • Explore Lean
        • What is Lean?
        • The Lean Transformation Framework
        • A Brief History of Lean
        • Lexicon Terms
        • Topics to explore
          • Operations
          • Lean Product and Process Development
          • Administration & Support
          • Problem-Solving
          • Coaching
          • Executive Leadership
          • Line Management
  • The Lean Post
        • Subscribe to see exclusive content
          • Subscribe
        • Featured posts

          Revisiting the Toyota Production System in the...

          coach mentoring two young employees

          Raising the Floor and the Ceiling: How...

          • See all Posts
  • Events & Courses
        • 2027 Lean Summit
          March 16-17
        • Forms and Templates
        • Featured learning
          • Building a Lean Operating and Management System 

            November 19, 2026 | Morgantown, PA

          • Managing in Time with Daily Management

            January 15, 2027 | Coach-Led Online Course

          • The Lean Management Program

            February 05, 2027 | Coach-led Online Program

          • Lean Warehousing and Distribution Operations

            February 17, 2027 | CITY Home in Plant City, FL

          • See all Events
  • Consulting & Training for Organizations​
        • Interested in exploring a partnership with us?
          • Schedule a Call
        • Getting Started with LEI
        • Enterprise Workshops and Training
        • Leadership Development
        • Lean Product and Process Development
        • Lean Enterprise Transformation​
        • Case Studies
  • LeanAI
  • Store
        • Book Ordering Information
        • Shopping Cart
        • Featured books

          The Work of a Chief Engineer: Inside Toyota’s Revolutionary Product Development System

          Daily Management to Execute Strategy: Solving problems and developing people every day

          • See all Books
  • About Us
        • Our people
          • Senior Advisors and Staff
          • Faculty
          • Board of Directors
        • Contact Us
        • Lean Global Network
        • Press Releases
        • In the News
        • Careers
        • About us

The Lean Post / Articles / How Many Whys Should I Ask?

Article graphic image with repeating icons

Coaching

How Many Whys Should I Ask?

By Tracey Richardson

October 7, 2011

Coach Tracey Richardson explains just how many whys to ask when conducting 5 Why analysis.

FacebookTweetLinkedInPrintComment

“Does it always have to be 5 Whys?” is one of the most frequent questions raised in my training classes. The answer is no. As with most lean tools, it’s important to understand the real purpose of this exercise. In this case, the “5 Why” label is meant to encourage you to ask why more than once or twice, in order to dig below the surface where the symptoms lie, and find the true root cause. The actual number of times you ask why is not critical: I have several examples where 2 why’s works best, and others where you might keep going until you’ve asked the question nine times. 

To practice this method you must go to the gemba to determine the actual cause and effect relationship of what is happening, engaging and involving those affected by the issue in the process. Conducting your investigation from behind a desk or in a conference room will often lead to fighting over symptoms not root causes. This approach will invariably be driven by theories and opinions rather than facts, facts, facts. Avoid the temptation to rely on preconceived notions since they often take less time to investigate. Whenever I hear that time is an issue, I reflect on a quote by the late John Wooden: “If you don’t have the time to do it right the first time, when will you have time to do it over?”

If you don’t have the time to do it right the first time, when will you have time to do it over?

John Wooden

The important issue with this process is not to go too far. Continuing to ask why after you have located the root cause will change the context of the problem, or the scope of control you may have in forming appropriate countermeasures. You want to make sure that your countermeasure effectively addresses the root cause, and all the symptoms up the chain. You want to reach the level at which making a change will effectively and permanently address the symptom that prompted this exercise. (By the way, clearly seeing the chain of events helps you focus on seeing how the root cause of the problem is tied to one of three categories—lack of Standard, lack of following Standard, or wrong Standard—as opposed to being the “fault” of individual people.)

Consider the following example:

Problem: I was late for work.

  • Why? I was unable to get there on time.
  • Why? I overslept.
  • Why? My alarm clock didn’t go off.
  • Why? The clocking wasn’t operating as it normally does, in this case flashing when I woke up.
  • Why? There was an interruption in the power overnight. (Root Cause)
  • Why? There were lightning storms in the area.
  • Why? Hot and cold clouds in the atmosphere collided.
  • Why? Barometric changes took place.
  • Why? The jet stream causes changes to weather patterns.
  • Why? There are cycles to the seasons on Earth.
  • Why? The Earth rotates.

So. Determining that the earth rotates takes our series of whys way too far. This is what happens if you keep asking why. You change the context of the problem. If I try to form a countermeasure based on this exercise, the logical one being to change the rotation of the earth, how will that address my problem of being late? I’ve set my sights on something that is not within my control.

By recognizing that the overnight interruption in power is the root cause of this problem, I can form an effective countermeasure. I can deal with the power interruption by having battery backups. So while I can’t control the outcome of uninterrupted electricity, I can still address and resolve the problem. Going further than this would be a useless foray into issues that are beyond your scope of control.

Finally, as a good way of checking on your 5 Why experience, it’s good practice to ask WHY downward, and THEREFORE upward, as way of establishing Cause and Effect in your chain.

FacebookTweetLinkedInPrintComment

Written by:

Tracey Richardson

About Tracey Richardson

Tracey has over 29 years of combined experience in various roles within Toyota and learned lean practices as a group leader at Toyota Motor Manufacturing Kentucky from 198 to 1998. She was one of the first team members hired, with the fortunate opportunity to learn directly from Japanese trainers. As…

Read more about Tracey Richardson

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related

WLEI Barton Malow Podcast

Coaching

Building a Problem-Solving Culture: Insights from Barton Malow’s Lean University

Podcast by Matthew Savas

experiements

Coaching

Lean Was Always an Experiment 

Article by Josh Howell

hands holding profile images with gears being shared to coney knowledge transfer

Coaching

Toyota’s Answer to Knowledge Walking Out the Door

Article by Fran Noto

Related books

A3 Getting Started Guide 2

A3 Getting Started Guide

by Lean Enterprise Institute

The Gold Mine (Audio CD)

The Gold Mine (Audio CD)

by Freddy Ballé and Michael Ballé

Related events

February 05, 2027 | Coach-led Online Program

The Lean Management Program

Learn more

February 25, 2027 | Gilbarco Veeder-Root | Greensboro, NC

Standardized Work: Foundations to Practice

Learn more

Explore topics

Coaching graphic icon Coaching
Line Management graphic icon Line Management

Sign up to be notified about new events

Subscribe
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

©Copyright 2000-2026 Lean Enterprise Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
Lean Enterprise Institute, the leaper image, and stick figure are registered trademarks of Lean Enterprise Institute, Inc.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Learn More. ACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT