Lean Enterprise Institute Logo
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter Signup
  • Cart (0)
  • Account
  • Search
Lean Enterprise Institute Logo
  • Explore Lean
        • What is Lean?
        • The Lean Transformation Framework
        • A Brief History of Lean
        • Lexicon Terms
        • Topics to explore
          • Operations
          • Lean Product & Process Development
          • Administration & Support
          • Problem-Solving
          • Coaching
          • Executive Leadership
          • Line Management
  • The Lean Post
        • Subscribe to see exclusive content
          • Subscribe
        • Featured posts
          make awards logo 2023

          Two LEI Learning Group Partner Executives Honored...

          Leaper climbing to goal

          Understanding Lean Thinking and Practice Fundamentals

          • See all Posts
  • Events & Training
        • Leadership Coaching and Custom Training
        • What is a Co-Learning Partnership (CLP)?
        • Forms and Templates
        • Featured learning
          • Improvement Kata/Coaching Kata Remotely

            April 10, 2023 | Online Live Course

          • Developing Structured Problem-Solving and Leadership Skills using A3 Thinking: Managing to Learn Remotely

            April 17, 2023 | Online Live Course

          • Hoshin Kanri Remotely: Aligning and Executing on Your Organizational Objectives

            April 21, 2023 | Online Live Course

          • Designing the Future Remotely: A Lean Product Development Immersive Learning Experience

            April 24, 2023 | Online Live Course

          • See all Events
  • Store
        • Shopping Cart
        • Featured books
          Managing to Learn: Using the A3 management process

          Managing to Learn: Using the A3 management process

          Learning to See

          Learning to See

          • See all Books
  • About Us
        • Our people
          • Senior Advisors and Staff
          • Faculty
          • Board of Directors
        • Contact Us
        • Lean Global Network
        • Press Releases
        • In the News
        • Careers
        • About us

The Lean Post / Articles / Practicing Constructive Discontent At SBP

a group of people standing in a room

Problem Solving

Practicing Constructive Discontent At SBP

By Zack Rosenburg

May 24, 2019

To become an organization of problem solvers, talking about problems couldn’t merely be something that we did, shares Zack Rosenburg of St. Bernard Project. It had to be part of who we are; it had to be our identity. Being or living constructive discontent and adopting it as our identity would mean that problems were brought to the surface, not buried.

FacebookTweetLinkedInEmailPrintComment

When we (Liz McCartney and I) first realized that sustaining continuous improvement in our work required us to become an organization of problem solvers, we also discovered that we were not thrilled with the phrase continuous improvement, which felt a bit like a hamster on a wheel. And so, with the input of our board member, former President of UPS Jerry Matters, we instead referred to this fundamental mindset of looking for problems to solve as constructive dissatisfaction.

We liked this term, except for the ‘dissatisfaction’ part. Like the leaders at UPS, we wanted our people to be in consistent pursuit of something better. Zack thought about Frederick Douglas writing, “Where there is no struggle, there is no progress.” He wanted to embrace the struggle—to encourage discontent—even while avoiding the sense that we were all rodents on wheels. So we arrived at constructive discontent to talk about problems and the search for improvement.

Constructive discontent because our ethos, woven into the fabric of our culture. We wanted it to become part of our identity. We had read in Switch, the business book about change by brothers Dan and Chip Heath, that the driver of decision making is not, as you would think, a rational choice assessment. Instead, what impels most decisions is identity. We ask ourselves, “What would a person like me do in a situation like this?”

To become an organization of problem solvers, talking about problems couldn’t merely be something that we did. It had to be part of who we are; it had to be our identity. Being or living constructive discontent and adopting it as our identity would mean that problems were brought to the surface, not buried. We began wrapping up meetings with the question, “Is there any constructive discontent to talk about?”

Sure, this is just a nice way of asking whether there are any problems to discuss. But the positive language turned out to be really important. Our people had found it difficult to stick up a hand and say they had noticed a problem. Partly this was due to the fact that the majority of our team members are time-limited AmeriCorps members; some of them probably felt intimidated. But we also had a lot of optimistic, helpful people on staff who did not like to criticize others and could fall into a pattern of heroically taking on problems alone.

Embracing an identity of constructive discontent took talking about problems from being optional to being a core part of who we are and how we interact with the world. We needed a way to hardwire addressing problems into our culture. We needed people to want to uncover and talk about difficulties, to seek out problems—like hunting wild nutria.

HUNTING PROBLEMS LIKE NUTRIA

For those of you unacquainted with them, nutria are large semi-aquatic rodents that were once raised for their fur on an island off the coast of Louisiana. Then a hurricane smashed their fences and helped them spread to the mainland. Their status quickly changed from business asset to burrowing, destructive pests (a.k.a. river rats). They were everywhere, but people did not like to talk about them and nobody wanted their fur anymore. They were without value. The state, however, needed to address the issue of too many nutrias. So the state offered a bounty—cash money—for nutria tails. And the rodents became worthy of hunting.

The question is, how do we get people to hunt river rats—problems—without a bounty? The answer we found has two parts: 1) to make problem hunting part of the training and deliverable work of our Americorps members and staff and 2) adopt change on a personal level.

Let’s start with the easy part, which is teaching problem hunting to our Americorps members during their 10-month stint. This is a new idea for SBP and has only been implemented in New Orleans (to date), but we are excited about the results so far.

At SBP we make a promise to Americorps to give training in what we call “Life After Americorps.” It makes sense to teach TPS skills as part of this promise, even though it is a large undertaking.

SBP has 50 full-time staff members and more than 180 AmeriCorps members at any given time. That means we have 140% turnover every 10 months. To make it work, SBP staff had to learn how to be TPS coaches to mentor Americorps members through problem-hunting training projects.

We had a finite amount of time with every AmeriCorps member, so we knew we needed to be very clear about our expectations from the beginning and plan for each step of their education. For instance, site supervisors received six weeks of training before they worked on their own. This included specific instructions on construction processes, how to teach and inspire volunteers to build houses, and what we mean by TPS.

HOW TO OPERATIONALIZE CONSTRUCTIVE DISCONTENT

During AmeriCorps orientation in New Orleans (which happens four to six times a year to accommodate staggered starting dates) we have a TSSC advisor come in and give a half day of training on the philosophy of TPS. Members learn about respect for people, bringing problems to the surface, and knowing whether we are ahead or behind. They learn about identifying waste and how to solve problems. Even if they do not have perfect recall following this training they have at least been introduced to the ideas.

AmeriCorps members usually need between one to three months to master their jobs as site supervisors, supply and logistics coordinators, or in client services. After that—right around their fourth or fifth month with us—it is time for a member to identify at least one problem to solve. That’s when we start mentoring them through problem solving, forming teams, and completing each step of the process for implementing countermeasures.

The first step is identifying a problem, using observation and collected data, and then writing a description of it that is specific yet open-ended. We do not want anyone to presume a solution or cast blame in their problem statement, so members receive coaching as they write.

Then we put together a team to address the problem. Sometimes these teams have members from across the functional areas, other times everyone is in the same department. Team makeup is decided by the nature of the problem and whether a coach thinks the team needs an outside perspective. Time, or lack thereof, and availability are also factors.

Teams are then taught to work through each of the seven problem-solving steps together:

  1. Go see the problem at the point of occurrence.
  2. Collect facts (a record of events) and data (measurements of those events) regarding the problem.
  3. Set a future target condition and date for completion.
  4. Perform root cause analysis using the 5 Whys.
  5. Analyze the factors involved, including the people, the materials or machines, and the methods used.
  6. Analyze the proposed countermeasures for effects on the organization.
  7. Create a plan: who does what, when, in order to put the countermeasures in place?

It is important to note that Toyota emphasizes finding countermeasures to problems, not solutions. A solution sounds like there is one right answer. But we know that a better countermeasure to a problem might be found in the future and that any countermeasure is likely to create new problems, even as it “solves” the immediate one.

This improvement work itself calls for ongoing “constructive discontent.” But we intend to maintain a disciplined focus on this effort. Creating a positive, problem-solving culture encourages flexibility and creativity.

To Do:

  • Buy a copy of Getting Home to be inspired while getting improvement ideas from SBP’s proven business methods for people management, continuous improvement, and developing a respectful, problem-solving culture based on values.

 

FacebookTweetLinkedInEmailPrintComment

Written by:

Zack Rosenburg

About Zack Rosenburg

Zack co-founded SBP with his wife Liz McCartney, after volunteering in New Orleans six months after Hurricane Katrina.  Disturbed by the lack rebuilding and predictability of recovery for most families, Zack and Liz began asking hard questions to understand the factors leading to the intolerable conditions faced by disaster survivors. From this desire to minimize the suffering caused by delayed recovery, the trial attorney and school teacher began rebuilding homes for New Orleans most vulnerable populations.


Leveraging private-sector innovations from Toyota and philosophies from UPS, Zack transformed SBP, adopting a culture of problem-solving by teaching staff and AmeriCorps members to surface them at every level. This ethos of continuous discontent has enabled SBP to become the leading long-term recovery nonprofit, rebuilding more than 1,860 homes nationwide, and has grown to include more than 30,000 volunteers annually, 240 AmeriCorps members and 76 staff.


SBP now looks at a host of interventions designed to shrink the time between disaster and recovery, resulting in much-needed systems change in an otherwise unchanging landscape that is disaster recovery. Zack and Liz co-authored the book, Getting Home, which was released in March of 2019.


Getting Home chronicles the founding of SBP, and how SBP partnered with Toyota to apply the lean principles of the Toyota Production System (TPS) to rebuild homes and lives following natural disasters throughout the U.S. and its territories, creating a culture of continuous improvement within SBP to reduce the duration of time between disaster and recovery.

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related

WLEI Podcast with author Paulo Savaget of The Four Workarounds

Problem Solving

Strategies for Tackling Complex Problems: a Conversation with Paolo Savaget

Podcast by Tom Ehrenfeld

man at wall putting puzzle together

Problem Solving

Learning to Solve Problems By… Wait for It… Solving Problems

Article by Josh Howell

Animation on Starting a Lean Journey

Problem Solving

Getting Started with Lean Thinking and Practice

Video by James (Jim) Womack, PhD

Related books

The Power of Process – A Story of Innovative Lean Process Development

The Power of Process – A Story of Innovative Lean Process Development

by Eric Ethington and Matt Zayko

Welcome Problems, Find Success – Creating Toyota Cultures Around the World

Welcome Problems, Find Success – Creating Toyota Cultures Around the World

by Nate Furuta

Related events

April 10, 2023 | Online Live Course

Improvement Kata/Coaching Kata Remotely

Learn more

April 17, 2023 | Online Live Course

Developing Structured Problem-Solving and Leadership Skills using A3 Thinking: Managing to Learn Remotely

Learn more

Explore topics

Problem Solving graphic icon Problem Solving
Coaching graphic icon Coaching

Subscribe to get the very best of lean thinking delivered right to your inbox

Subscribe
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

©Copyright 2000-2023 Lean Enterprise Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
Lean Enterprise Institute, the leaper image, and stick figure are registered trademarks of Lean Enterprise Institute, Inc.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Learn More. ACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT
Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!